In Poor Charlie’s Almanack, Charlie Munger outlines his investment principles in the form of a checklist—a disciplined way to reduce bias, focus on fundamentals, and avoid costly mistakes. Leaders evaluating people, whether current employees or new hires face a similar challenge. Emotions, urgency, or reputation often cloud judgment. What if we applied Munger’s checklist mindset to talent decisions?

Below is a structured framework senior executives can use to evaluate leaders and high-potential employees objectively. It is designed not as a formula, but as a disciplined way to ask the right questions.

1. Character

The foundation of trust and leadership potential.

  • Does this person consistently demonstrate integrity, even under pressure?
  • Do their actions align with stated values, or are there gaps?
  • How do they handle accountability—do they own mistakes or deflect?

2. Work Ethic and Work Style

Beyond effort—are they effective and sustainable?

  • Do they consistently follow through, or do they overpromise and underdeliver?
  • How do they structure their day—are they proactive or reactive?
  • Are they disciplined in the details that matter, or do they thrive only in crisis mode?

3. Interpersonal and Soft Skills

The currency of influence in modern organizations.

  • How do peers, subordinates, and clients describe working with them?
  • Can they build trust quickly in new relationships?
  • Do they adjust their communication style for different audiences?

4. Intellectual Capacity

Not just IQ—applied judgment and adaptability.

  • How quickly do they grasp complex information or ambiguous problems?
  • Do they connect dots across disciplines, or stay siloed?
  • Can they simplify complexity for others, or do they add confusion?

5. Decisiveness

The ability to make the right call under uncertainty.

  • Do they have a track record of timely, sound decisions?
  • Do they seek input appropriately without falling into analysis paralysis?
  • How do they respond when a decision turns out wrong—do they course-correct or double down?

6. Emotional Intelligence

Self-awareness and resilience in action.

  • Do they recognize their emotional triggers and manage them constructively?
  • How do they respond to stress, conflict or setbacks?
  • Do they elevate the team’s energy—or drain it?

7. Experience in the Industry

Context matters—but it isn’t everything.

  • Have they demonstrated success in relevant market conditions?
  • Are they learning and adapting as the industry evolves, or relying on outdated playbooks?
  • Do they bring outside perspectives that challenge conventional thinking?

8. Performance in the Job (Then vs. Now)

Past results don’t always predict future success.

  • What explains their historical standout performance? Was it individual skill, team context or favorable conditions?
  • Are they equally effective in new roles (e.g., the top engineer promoted to project manager who now struggles)?
  • If performance slipped, is it a skills gap, a role misfit or a motivation issue?

Applying the Checklist as a Leader

When evaluating current employees:

  • Which of these categories explain their strengths—and which explain their struggles?
  • Are underperformers in the wrong seat, or do they lack the capacity to grow into it?
  • What interventions (mentorship, realignment, or exit) make the most sense?

When considering new senior hires:

  • Are we overly influenced by a polished résumé or big-company brand?
  • Have we validated not just what they achieved, but how?
  • Have we probed for the conditions under which they thrive—and those where they falter?

The Leadership Imperative

Charlie Munger once said, “Checklist routines avoid a lot of errors.” For executives, this is more than a hiring tool. It’s a lens for diagnosing performance, removing bias, and ensuring leaders are placed where they can thrive.

The cost of a mis-hire—or of allowing a current leader to languish in the wrong role—is measured not just in dollars, but in opportunity lost, morale eroded, and talent squandered. A checklist discipline helps leaders cut through emotion and act on facts.

The question isn’t whether your people are talented. The question is: are they in the right roles, at the right time, with the right support?

#munger #hiringprep #employeereview #evaluation #assessment #risk #career #jobs